Shelsky’s Of Brooklyn Appetizing and Delicatessen is a kosher café and deli in Brooklyn.
Shelsky's Of Brooklyn Appetizing and Delicatessen draws attention from the community for its fresh ingredients, with the tuna salad featuring sliced jalapeños and spicy shrimp paste receiving particular praise for its heat level and quality. Customer reviews note that the establishment maintains a clean, well-organized space with polite and friendly staff.
Pricing reflects premium positioning, with sandwiches ranging from approximately $12 to $29, though experiences with portion sizes and meat-to-bread ratios vary. Some visitors report discrepancies between displayed menu board prices and final charges, particularly when customizations are added. The corned beef sandwich has received mixed feedback regarding moisture levels and bread texture, with fattier cut options available but not always communicated during ordering.
The team at Shelsky's emphasizes the use of fresh, high-quality ingredients that deliver noticeable flavor profiles across menu offerings.
A Decade of Editorial Insights
10+ Years of Expert Curation
Compare this listing with other Kosher Cafés & Delis in Brooklyn. For over 11 years, Simcha Center has specialized in identifying top-rated providers with a proven community reputation.
July, 2026
Tuesday
August 26,2019
Awesome Job!
We have received your appointment and will send you a confirmation to your provided email upon approval.
Own or work here?